The Decline of the Traditional Number 9: What’s Replacing It
For decades, the Number 9 shirt symbolized one thing — the out-and-out striker. Think of Alan Shearer, Filippo Inzaghi, or Didier Drogba. These were players who lived for goals, often stationed high up the pitch, feeding off crosses, through balls, and defensive mistakes. But watch a top-level match today, and you’ll notice something different.
The role of the traditional No. 9 is fading — and a new era of attackers is reshaping how we understand goal-scoring in modern football.
What Was the Traditional Number 9?
Historically, the number 9 was the team’s spearhead. A physical presence in the box, this player was typically strong, good in the air, and had a natural instinct for goal. They didn’t need to drop deep or get involved in build-up play — their job was simple: score.
The game plan often revolved around them. Wingers and midfielders created; the No. 9 finished.
What’s Changed?
Football, like any sport, evolves — and in recent years, tactical shifts have drastically redefined forward roles. Several factors have contributed to the decline of the classic striker:
1. The Rise of Pressing Football
Modern managers demand relentless pressing from the front. Strikers are now the first defenders. Traditional target men, often not built for non-stop pressing, struggle in systems that require constant movement and defensive contribution.
2. More Emphasis on Build-Up Play
Today’s forwards are expected to be more than finishers. They need to drop deep, link up with midfielders, create space, and even act as playmakers. This multi-functional role is far from the poacher mentality of old.
3. Tactical Fluidity
Formations are more flexible now. Many teams operate without a clear “striker,” instead rotating between a false 9, inside forwards, or attacking midfielders. Players constantly switch positions, confusing defenders and creating dynamic attacking systems.
4. Rise of Data and Analytics
Coaches and analysts now look beyond goals. Pressing stats, passing combinations, and movement off the ball are increasingly valued. A striker who scores but offers little else may not fit the modern model.
Who’s Replacing the Classic Number 9?
Instead of one traditional forward, teams now use attackers with hybrid roles. Here are some of the alternatives dominating the game:
🔹 The False 9
A player who drops into midfield instead of staying high. Lionel Messi revolutionized this role under Guardiola at Barcelona. Today, players like Kai Havertz or Phil Foden occasionally operate in this space, dragging defenders out of position and creating chaos.
🔹 Inside Forwards
These are wingers who cut inside to become goal threats. Mohamed Salah and Kylian Mbappé are prime examples. They often outscore central strikers by arriving from wide positions with pace and timing.
🔹 Mobile Strikers
Think of Karim Benzema or Gabriel Jesus — players who still play centrally but are constantly on the move, linking play, drifting wide, and creating space for others.
🔹 Multi-Role Attackers
Erling Haaland is a rare blend: a physical presence with elite pace and movement. Though he wears the No. 9 and plays centrally, even he contributes more to buildup than strikers of the past.
Is the Traditional 9 Gone Forever?
Not quite. There’s still a place for a physical goal poacher, especially in teams that play direct football or rely on crosses. Olivier Giroud, for instance, has aged gracefully as a classic striker thanks to his hold-up play and aerial dominance.
But even those strikers now offer more than just goals — they must adapt or risk becoming obsolete.
What This Means for Young Players and Coaches
Aspiring forwards must now be complete footballers. They can’t rely solely on finishing ability. Coaches should develop strikers with:
Good link-up and combination play
Intelligent movement and positioning
Work rate off the ball
Awareness of how to create space for teammates
It’s no longer about being in the box at the right time — it’s about contributing to every phase of the attack.
Conclusion: Evolution, Not Extinction
The traditional No. 9 hasn’t disappeared — it’s evolved. While the pure poacher may be rare at the top level, goal scorers are still essential. What’s changed is how they score and what else they bring to the team.
In this modern era of football, the most successful forwards are those who do more than finish — they connect, press, create, and adapt. And that’s a trend that’s here to stay.